Lawyers Argue Scotty David Shouldn’t Have Served on Ghislaine Maxwell’s Jury

Lawyers Say Scotty David Shouldn't Have Been on Ghislaine Maxwell's Jury

( – In 2021, the courts convicted former British socialite Ghislaine Maxwell of child sex trafficking. The case hinged on whether she groomed and procured teenage girls for the late and very much disgraced financier Jeffrey Epstein, an accusation both Maxwell and her lawyers staunchly deny.

Recently, Maxwell’s legal team has been arguing for a new trial on the basis that a key juror, Scotty David, failed to disclose a conflict of interest. During a March 8 hearing, David said he didn’t remember to disclose his past sexual abuse from childhood during jury screening, which included a survey with questions about past experiences. David told Judge Alison Nathan that the screening process flew by; it didn’t occur to him to clarify further.

However, Maxwell’s lawyers didn’t buy that explanation. In a court filing after the hearing, they said David’s insistence that his past experiences didn’t impact his ability to be a fair juror were “not believable.” They argued the takeaway from the hearing was that “he should never have been a member of this jury.”

Federal prosecutor Damian Williams, on the other hand, said that David made an honest mistake and would have become a jury member either way, even if he disclosed his history from day one. Judge Nathan has yet to hand down a ruling on the statement discrepancy, but the prosecution team remains confident she will agree with their point of view.

While Maxwell’s team says David shouldn’t have been on the jury, others are arguing that Maxwell received a fair trial and an acceptable sentence for her crimes. Even though jurors must express any conflicting past experiences before being assigned to the jury, this case demonstrates the importance of clear and honest communication in justice.

What’s your opinion? Should the transgression serve as just cause for a second trial? Or, is this just a desperate attempt to overturn a conviction for a grave crime?

Copyright 2022,