Exploring Trump’s Self-Deportation Idea Through Heritage Foundation’s Lens

The Trump administration has unveiled the ‘CBP Home’ app allowing illegal immigrants to self-deport, potentially offering a pathway to legal return while implementing stricter border enforcement measures.

Key Takeaways

The Department of Homeland Security has rebranded the Biden-era ‘CBP One’ app as ‘CBP Home’, adding a self-deportation feature.
President Trump had previously shut down the ‘CBP One’ app on his first day in office before relaunching it with new features.
A $200 million advertising campaign accompanies the app launch, warning illegal immigrants to leave or face deportation.
The Heritage Foundation supports the initiative as a means for illegal aliens to potentially return legally in the future.
Critics express concern about data collection and the removal of features for scheduling asylum appointments.

Trump Administration Transforms Border Management App

The Department of Homeland Security has officially relaunched the controversial ‘CBP One’ app as ‘CBP Home’, featuring a new self-deportation option for illegal immigrants currently in the United States. This transformation marks a significant shift in immigration enforcement strategy under President Trump’s second term. The original ‘CBP One’ app, developed during the Biden administration, was designed to schedule asylum appointments at the border and had processed over 900,000 appointments before being shut down by Trump on his first day back in office.

The updated ‘CBP Home’ app now allows immigrants to signal their intent to leave the United States voluntarily by uploading personal information, potentially avoiding arrest and detention. Additional features include applying and paying for an I-94 form and checking border wait times. DHS officials have confirmed that the ‘CBP One’ app will automatically update to ‘CBP Home’, though usage patterns remain uncertain.

CBP Home App – Allows Illegal Aliens to Self-Deport

Illegal Aliens who Self-Deport may apply to return to US pic.twitter.com/tpE37Fsdc3

— DogeWatchReport (@DogeWatchReport) March 10, 2025

Heritage Foundation Backs Self-Deportation Initiative

The Heritage Foundation, a prominent conservative think tank, has expressed support for the ‘CBP Home’ app as part of the administration’s broader immigration enforcement strategy. Lora Ries from The Heritage Foundation endorsed the app as an effective means for illegal aliens to self-deport with the possibility of returning through legal channels in the future. This aligns with the Trump administration’s dual approach of encouraging voluntary departures while simultaneously ramping up enforcement operations against those who remain illegally.

The administration has launched a substantial $200 million advertising campaign alongside the app to inform illegal immigrants about their options and the consequences of remaining in the country unlawfully. Secretary Noem has emphasized that the initiative aims to restore integrity to the immigration system, claiming the previous administration had exploited the ‘CBP One’ app to allow more than one million aliens to illegally enter the United States.

Legal Concerns and Practical Challenges

Immigration attorneys have raised significant concerns about the app’s implementation and its potential consequences for users. Darius Amiri, a prominent immigration attorney, expressed skepticism about the app’s true purpose, suggesting it could function more as a data collection tool for future deportation operations than a genuine pathway to legal return. The so-called “10-year bar” law presents a significant obstacle, as it prevents reentry for ten years for those unlawfully present in the U.S. for over a year, directly affecting many who might consider self-deportation.

Despite these concerns, the administration reports that monthly border crossings have decreased significantly during Trump’s second presidency, suggesting that the mere announcement of stricter enforcement policies may be having an impact on migration patterns even before widespread deportations begin.

Weighing the Effectiveness of Digital Self-Deportation

While the administration presents the ‘CBP Home’ app as a compassionate alternative to forced removal, allowing illegal immigrants to depart on their own terms, immigration experts remain divided on whether significant numbers will actually utilize the feature. Some immigrants might prefer self-deportation over the risks of arrest, detention, and forced removal, especially if there is a genuine pathway to legal return in the future. However, many undocumented individuals with established lives in the United States may be reluctant to abandon their current situations without stronger guarantees of legal reentry.

As the program develops, its success will likely be measured not only by the number of self-deportations it facilitates but also by its contribution to the administration’s broader goal of reducing illegal immigration while promoting legal pathways for those seeking to enter the United States.